Helen Osborne: Welcome to Health Literacy Out Loud. I’m Helen Osborne, president of Health Literacy Consulting, founder of Health Literacy Month, and author of the book Health Literacy from A to Z. I also produce and host this Health Literacy Out Loud podcast series that focuses on many aspects of health communication, patient education, and health literacy. Today’s guests are Carissa Bonner and Danielle Muscat, who both are at the University of Sydney in Australia.
Associate Professor Carissa Bonner is a behavioral scientist and deputy director of the Sydney Health Literacy Lab at the University of Sydney. She is founding co-editor-in-chief of the journal Health Literacy and Communication Open. Carissa leads a national partnership on heart health literacy and is a scientific advisor to the World Health Organization and International Patient Decision Aid Standards on health risk communication.
Danielle Muscat, otherwise known as Dani, is an associate professor in the University of Sydney Health Literacy Lab, advisor on health literacy to the World Health Organization, and co-editor-in-chief of the Health Literacy and Communication Open Journal. Dani’s research focuses on the development and evaluation of interventions to improve health literacy at individual, community, and systems levels.
Individually, together, and with health literacy advocates across Australia and around the world, Carissa and Dani are making a lasting impact on health literacy research and practice. In our preliminary conversation, it came out that neither one of them foresaw that any of this would happen. I’m delighted we’re now having a conversation about how one person’s passion can make a worldwide difference. Welcome to Health Literacy Out Loud.
Carissa Bonner: Thanks, Helen.
Danielle Muscat: Thanks, Helen.
Helen Osborne: Your stories are amazing for what you’re doing now. You’re doing so much when it comes to health literacy. I’m in awe of it. But that’s not where your stories started. I’d love to hear from each of you just a bit about when and why and how you realize that health literacy really mattered.
Because it’s three women, two with Australia accents, I’m hoping that you will identify yourself, at least in the beginning, until everyone can distinguish all our voices.
Danielle Muscat: Sure, I’ll go first. It’s really funny as I don’t think I have an accent and then I speak with international colleagues and they’re like, you definitely have an accent.
Helen Osborne: And you are Dani.
Danielle Muscat: I’m Dani, thanks, and thanks for having us, Helen, and hi, everyone who’s listening. Yeah, so I started my journey in health literacy as an academic. I did my PhD in a health literacy lab here at the University of Sydney, so it was really doing research, very focused on, you know, doing academic research, rigorous research.
Helen Osborne: I want to step that back a little bit.
Danielle Muscat: Yeah, absolutely.
Helen Osborne: So you’re doing your PhD in a health literacy lab, but what happened? There was something that got you to that point. There you are growing up wherever you’re growing up, and then you go to college and you do whatever you do. And then how did you decide that that’s what you wanted to focus on?
Danielle Muscat: Yeah, thanks. It’s really nice to actually kind of sit and reflect. So I’m from a migrant family to Australia. My grandparents who were born overseas face a lot of health issues. I think, unfortunately that comes with lots of challenges navigating health systems, understanding health information. I think that what was always really important to me was about the importance of clear communication.
I did an undergraduate degree in psychology but in our university there is quite an emphasis on health psychology. And a lot of that is about health communication. So that really resonated with me. I was really passionate about doing projects in that area. And so I did an honours project about communicating risks related with CT scans.
That feels like a lifetime ago. But it really grew my passion about kind of clear communication. Back then, you know, less of a focus than it is now. So there was lots of really complex information being shared. So it was something that kind of really resonated.
And then I went on to do my PhD with Professor Kirsten McCaffrey, and we were actually looking at the adult education space. So how can we embed health literacy within adult basic education programs here in Australia. So again, that was a lot of students who were kind of recent arrivals in Australia. So many migrant backgrounds or who may not have kind of completed the education here in Australia for a number of reasons. So that was a really kind of grounding experience. It was working directly with students at our education centres. And I really loved it.
And I always joke kind of I stayed in research since then. I’ve kind of never left the University of Sydney. But I think it’s because I have been able to work on projects that aren’t so academic and, you know, ivory tower. It’s really been with communities trying to kind of either build health literacy skills in communities and in patients and/or kind of working with health systems to improve the way we communicate. So that’s been really nice.
Helen Osborne: Thank you for sharing that story. I didn’t know all that about you. I met you and you’re already like this whole fully packaged deal of doing all this awesome stuff. But you started just like all of us. We all start somewhere. And thank you for sharing about your family’s background.
I’m amazed and it’s awesome that in your school system, in undergraduate, they’re focusing on health communication. That’s really impressive. And then all your work in adult education. So thank you. What about you, Carissa?
Carissa Bonner: Yeah, so I also have a background in psychology, but I was more focused on cognitive psychology. So I was interested in heuristics and biases and how that shapes the way that people understand risk. And I always had an interest in applying that to the health context. So I only came over to public health from psychology a little bit after that because I was sort of finding these cognitive psychology theories are really interesting, but they’re not really doing anything when you just publish an experiment in an academic paper. So I really wanted to do more applied work, which is what brought me to the same lab as Dani to do my PhD.
But in terms of health literacy, the lab wasn’t called the health literacy lab then. It was called the communication lab. And the first time I suppose that health literacy really stood out to me as a really fundamental issue that we had to support was actually from my first PhD study, which was interviewing GPs.
Helen Osborne: Interviewing what?
Carissa Bonner: General practitioners. Sometimes called family physicians as well. And so I was interviewing them about how they assess heart disease risk and why they weren’t following the risk assessment guidelines necessarily. And one of the key reasons they weren’t doing that is they found it really hard to explain this idea of probabilistic risk to particular patients.
So they didn’t use the term health literacy then, but it essentially was an issue around health literacy in that they just didn’t know how to explain it in a clear way within a short consultation time. And it was actually making them avoid doing the assessment altogether in some cases.
So then when we talked to the patients, we realised that a lot of them really actually didn’t know why they were taking medications like statins and antihypertensives. So no one had actually explained to them that the reason you need to lower blood pressure and cholesterol is that you want to avoid a heart attack or a stroke. And that’s the whole purpose of taking the medication, but no one had ever explained that to them. They were just sort of following directions or often people would come off them because they didn’t really understand the side effects or the cost and no one had actually made that link for them to the health outcomes that were important to them.
Helen Osborne: Thank you. And as listeners might know if they’ve listened to other episodes, I come from a clinical background. So I had to be learning what both of you went into with the research and the practice and the academia. I saw it in everyday practice about why health literacy matters.
We’re all doing interesting work to advance understanding and health communication. Now, as we were initially talking, neither of you, even though you’re very knowledgeable in the research in this field, some of your awesome projects, your big projects, didn’t start that way. It didn’t happen in a lateral way. So the two biggest projects that I know that we talked about is this journal that you both co-edit, the Health Literacy and Communication Open Journal. And also, I just recently read about Australia’s National Health Literacy Framework. You’re both involved. They’re both gigantic projects. Let’s go a little bit further. Tell us how a project that started small grew to be so big.
Carissa Bonner: Well, maybe if I start with the journal, I was originally approached by Taylor and Francis to lead a third health communication journal in their portfolio. So they already had two health communication journals and they wanted to do another open access one. And so I had some reservations about whether there was really a need for a third journal in that space. But after talking to the editors of the other journals, I realised there was a gap in that they weren’t particularly interested in health literacy at that time, but they were getting lots of high-quality submissions that they had to reject as out of scope.
So I sort of argued to change the focus a little bit. So our journal is still about health communication, but also health literacy to make it a bit more distinct from the other journals in the portfolio.
I knew that Dani had amazing theoretical knowledge and international networks in health literacy so I asked her to join me to do it together. And we just started small. So we started with our more local network of really good researchers in both health communication and health literacy areas. And we invited them to the associate editors from the start rather than kind of leading everything just ourselves.
It was always really a collaborative team effort. And as the journal grew, we’ve tried to expand our international reach and include more and more board members from international locations and regions. And now I’m really excited to have just got the news that we are indexed in Scopus. So we’re now an official journal in the well-known scientific databases. And that’s a result of doing it as a team, a team effort.
Helen Osborne: That’s just amazing. And when you were talking about your background, you weren’t an editor to start with. You just kind of happened, a journal just approached you. I mean, so we come at this all these different ways. I was looking at your journal just today, again, to just catch up on it. The scope of the articles is awesome. We’re going to have a link on your Health Literacy Out Loud webpage to the journal so people can go see for themselves. And I applaud you and Taylor and Francis for keeping that open access. I’m very sincere in that appreciation.
Danielle Muscat: Thanks, Helen. I think for me, just on a kind of slightly personal, I don’t know about Carissa, I was quite daunted. You know, it was an exciting opportunity, but I think I was quite daunted and definitely, you know, something we spoke about, Helen, out of the comfort zone, you know, as academics, you publish articles. I’d done some associate editor work, but like leading a journal was really new and quite different. And so I think it was, you know, as Carissa said, it was nice to do it together, but also really rewarding to do something that’s slightly outside of exactly, you know, the things that you’re used to doing as an academic. It kind of puts you on the line a little bit and requires just a little, you know, it helps you to get an understanding, I think, of the way that things work in publishing, which is an area that we hadn’t kind of done a deep dive into.
So yeah, just stepping out of the comfort zone is always challenging, but I think it was really nice to do it and I think we’ve learned a lot along the way, which is fantastic.
Helen Osborne: Well, it’s a wonderful story to hear how you both went out of your traditional comfort zone in roles, but you’re doing it together. And you talked about the collaborative and the team effort. Is that something that has sustained you as you’re moving forward onto these big, big projects?
Danielle Muscat: Oh, for me, 100%. I think, you know, working with Carissa, others in our lab, but also other editors in the journal, like… It’s nice. We all are really passionate about something. Sometimes we come from different backgrounds and different areas, but it’s nice to be sustained by one another. And obviously, when things don’t always go well, you can, you know, draw on others for support and to kind of work through things as well. I think sometimes for me, particularly, there’s been some hurdles and some learning that we’ve had to kind of work through, but like having Carissa there and having the other editors and also in our lab for other projects that we’ve done, having others that you can kind of have as a sounding board is really helpful.
Helen Osborne: You’re both at the same university, so I’m sure you see each other on a regular basis. You talk about a health literacy lab at your university, but your journal is international in scope. What’s the makeup of that team there? It can’t be all in person. How do you work with a virtual team at such a high level?
Carissa Bonner: Yeah, so we’ve tried a few different structures over the few years we’ve been running the journal. So when we were a bit more locally focused, we did have kind of larger in-person meetings, but obviously that doesn’t work when you’re on multiple time zones. So we make sure that we’re in touch with our associate editors several times throughout the year to talk about any more strategic issues or operational issues, like how we’re going to deal with AI, which every journal is currently grappling with.
And then we have a once a year meeting with the whole editorial board. So that’s all our regular peer reviewers as well and guest editors. And just to make sure that we’re keeping in touch with them, letting them know where the journal’s going and also giving them the chance to come up with their ideas and things that they might want to pursue.
The model that we’re now running, I think, is working the best where we have associate editors running article collections in their particular areas of expertise. And we’re trying to make sure that that’s sort of spread around the world to make sure that they’re using their international networks properly.
We don’t always all get together, but we sort of are doing sort of sub projects within the journal, working in different regions. And then I guess the other thing that’s working well for us now, which we didn’t start with, is we have a social media editor, a commissioning editor and blogger. The social media editor, Ash Sharman, has done an amazing job and we’ve now got her a new position as managing editor. So Ash, Dani and I meet every week to go through all of the papers that are in our submission system and all of our kind of promotional activities. And then we meet with other sections of the editorial board to sort of push things along.
Helen Osborne: Thank you. You both seem to have learned a lot about leadership, too. It’s hard to manage a big team like that. The other big project that you talked about that I saw was this National Health Literacy Framework. I’m from the U.S. We had a National Action Plan for Health Literacy a number of years ago.
I read yours. It’s wonderful. Again, we’ll have a link on your Health Literacy Out Loud webpage to that. That’s another great big project, and that’s distinct from this journal. Did that happen in somewhat of this more happenstance manner, or did you go into it like, that’s what we want to do, and that’s what we’re going to do?
Danielle Muscat: For me (it’s Dani). For me, I think it was a good both, right? So we’ve been advocating for health literacy in Australia, not only in research, but also in policy and in government and in our accreditation standards for a long time. Again, that was kind of stepping out of the usual bounds of what academics might do and really trying to advocate to make sure that it gets into practice, it gets into policy.
There was a broader national preventative health strategy and health literacy was actually one of the key action items from that strategy. Which was lovely. And again, kind of, I think, a testament to the advocacy for health literacy that’s been happening in Australia. So they identified that we need to have a focus on health literacy. And that led to the commissioning of a national health literacy framework, which we were successful in being the scientific advisors on that framework.
So again, it challenged us a lot to think differently, to do something that was not, you know, a purely academic exercise. We talked to a lot of people, we held national consultations, but also had to understand the kind of policy landscape, how you shape policy, how you write a framework that’s a government document. And to do things slightly differently in that way.
Helen Osborne: And you’re building a team on that one, too. It’s just all your work, the outcomes are vast and wonderful.
But what tips do you have for listeners? People might be in public health, which is, you know, you both have a lot of work in public health and all that. And how do you spread the word about that on a community level? People might be at community organizations. A lot of our listeners are students, too, who are entering in the health fields, right? What tips would you have based on your journeys with health literacy, going from wherever you started in your disparate ways to where you are now? What would you want to share with those listeners?
Carissa Bonner: I’ve just been talking to a range of stakeholders about the framework that we’ve just launched and it’s kind of structured around four key aims. So I think it’s actually a really good framework for thinking through what you can do to support health literacy.
One area is around organisational systems and prioritising health literacy in policy from a higher level. So if you’re a hospital administrator, for example, that’s something that you can be thinking about. For a clinician, it might be about actually training yourself in how to use techniques like teach back, which we know work really well to help make sure that patients are leaving your consultation with a clear understanding of what they need to do next. And if you’re somebody who produces patient education materials, there’s also quite simple things you can do, like just checking the readability of the text that you’re putting out, including before translations into different languages.
And then the final aim for the framework is really around priority populations and just making sure that we’re not leaving any communities behind when we’re doing public health initiatives or explaining health issues and making sure that that’s accessible to people from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds.
Helen Osborne: Thank you. Are they part of your team?
Carissa Bonner: Yeah, the Sydney Health Literacy Lab has a consumer advisory panel called COSHELL. So we consult them on all our projects and a lot of our projects have specific advisory groups as well that have people from different communities depending on the focus of the project.
Helen Osborne: Thank you. And, Dani, we’ve gone so far with this. Let’s look ahead. Where do you see or where would you like to see health literacy going next?
Danielle Muscat: Yeah, everywhere. I want to see it going everywhere as I know you do and you’ve been advocating for so long, Helen. Yeah, I think we’ve made lots of progress. I really would like to kind of really continue to see in practice it kind of organizations making it easy for people to embed health literacy practice into their everyday kind of work. I, you know, I know that’s been your work for a lifetime, Helen, but I think, you know, we’ve got policies now in Australia of frameworks to help us and accreditation standards to help us with this.
It’s about kind of being able to make that happen on the ground. And I think kind of related to Carissa’s point about the way that we work really ensuring that in terms of research it is very much kind of consumer community led, right? So we’re doing, I think, much better job of making sure that they’re helping to define our research priorities. And I think that’s a really useful thing to kind of do across the board in health literacy.
Helen Osborne: Thank you. Thank you both. As you stated in the beginning and you shared in your stories, health literacy is really a collaborative team effort. You two are exemplifying that. Thank you. Thank you for all you’re doing and for being such awesome guests on Health Literacy Out Loud.
Carissa Bonner: Thank you.
Danielle Muscat: Thank you, Helen.
Helen Osborne: As we just heard from Carissa Bonner and Danielle Muscat, health literacy is really a team effort. It takes all of us working together to go from we know where it could be to where it is to where it goes next.
For help clearly communicating your health message, please take a look at my book, Health Literacy from A to Z. Feel free to also explore my website, healthliteracy.com, or contact me directly at helen at healthliteracy.com. New Health Literacy Out Loud interviews come out early each month. You can get them all for free by subscribing at healthliteracyoutloud.com or wherever you get your podcasts. Please help spread the word about Health Literacy Out Loud. Together, let’s tell the whole world why health literacy matters. Until next time, I’m Helen Osborne.

